Imam Cahyono and Ted Meinhover, Jakarta
These are critical days for U.S. President George W. Bush.
The global image of his administration continues to decline.
The past six years of his policies have been largely
disastrous and misguided. His main agendas, the war against
terrorism and democratization through force and the invasion
of Afghanistan and Iraq, have failed.
The Bush administration's foreign policy has resulted in
the creation of enemies and the loss of allies. Domestically,
the Bush administration's image continues to wane, as evident
in the recent defeat of the Republican Party in the midterm
elections. The economic condition in the U.S. continues to
worsen, growth is at a spectacular low, while the strength of
China and other countries continues to grow.
Under such circumstances, Bush's planned visit to Indonesia
on Nov. 20 is a recognition of the critical nature of his
situation. The official agenda of the meeting between Bush and
President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono at Bogor Palace will
include education, public health, bio-energy, information
technology and a tsunami early warning system. The meeting
will also focus on poverty reduction and the Millennium
Development Goals. The military and the political agenda that
inevitably follows the American president, however, cannot be
hidden. Indonesia's importance to Bush, at this critical
turning point in his presidency, is much greater than the
official agenda lets on.
The most damaging failure of the Bush administration has
been the invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan. Many Indonesians,
as well as the world, feel that these wars have hurt all
Muslims. Indonesia is perhaps America's best hope for building
a new, positive image within Islam. It plays a very important
role as not only the largest Muslim country in the world but
also the third most populous democracy in the world. The real
reason for Bush's visit is to build cooperation with
Indonesia, which can help it repair its relationship with the
Muslim world. Bush needs Indonesia's support to restore his
administration's image among Muslims.
While it has been focusing on its battle against terrorism
in the Middle East, the U.S. has eased its role in Asia, only
to allow Asia's major powers, like China, to take over. The
imported goods that once dominated Indonesia's market came
from the U.S. and Japan, but today, Chinese products prevail.
If China and Indonesia join forces, the powerful
relationship will further challenge the U.S. The strengthening
of Indo-Chinese ties indicates that the pendulum of
Indonesia's foreign policy is swinging toward China as a
consequence of U.S. neglect.
Furthermore, China and Indonesia are building military
relations that spark anxiety within the Bush administration.
Because of a history of arms embargo, Indonesia is trying to
reduce its dependency on the U.S. as a source of military
equipment.
In addition to its economic and military significance,
Indonesia was also recently chosen as a non-permanent member
of the United Nations Security Council. This means Indonesia's
role in the global community has strengthened. Not only is
Indonesia seen as an important player within the UN, it is
also an influential player in the Muslim world.
Bush needs Indonesia -- he has a challenge before him,
however, as thousands of people in Indonesia have taken to the
streets to protest his visit. When Bush is welcomed by massive
demonstrations in Bogor, it will show how he has already lost
much of his legitimacy.
For example, some of the most important moderate Islamic
leaders, such as Hasyim Muzadi of the Nahdlatul Ulama, have
spoken out against the meeting. It is ironic that despite the
need for reconciliation, Bush continues to show his arrogance
by demanding that Indonesia go to excessive lengths to provide
security. It is obvious that the American policies of the past
six years have already caused damage to its relations with the
Indonesian people.
Given these many challenges, Bush must reexamine his
approach to Indonesia and Islam. He must not only create new
relations with Indonesia, he must fix those that have been
damaged over the course of his presidency. Bush should
reconsider his approach of hard power, using violence and
military strength.
He has used fear, violence and aggression in pursuit of his
goals -- this has resulted in the creation of enemies and the
loss of allies. International surveys show that many people
see Bush as a greater threat to peace than even Kim Jong-il,
the leader of North Korea. This sentiment is obviously shared
by the thousands of Indonesians who have and are planning to
rally against the meeting between Bush and SBY.
Considering the extent to which Indonesia is needed by the
United States, it would be wise for Bush to take this
opportunity to apologize. By planning a meeting in Indonesia,
he has recognized that country's importance -- it also
indicates he has realized his policies have been faulty. He is
too arrogant, however, to take the next necessary step and
apologize for the damage they have done. His policies of
aggression have not only hurt and offended Muslims, but all
people who are united in their respect for humanity.
This is a crucial moment -- Bush must admit that he has
been wrong, and must continue to change his policies. In
Indonesia, Bush is often seen as too proud to make this
necessary apology. Considering the Indonesian tradition of
Idul Fitri as a time of forgiveness, the American president
should use this as an opportunity to say Minal Aidzin wal
Faizin (may you are among the winners and those who return
to the pure life), to heal damaged relations, and to gain
sympathy from Muslims. But it must be a sincere apology, and
it must be reinforced by a real change of U.S. policy.
The interests of the United States in terms of battling
terrorism and building economic ties are much better served by
helping Muslim countries battle poverty and improve education;
simply waging a "war on terror" will only create more enemies.
This may very well be the last chance for President Bush to
repair and to rebuild relationships with the Islamic world and
Indonesia. A failure to do so will speed the decline of the
American superpower and will further the violence that plagues
our world today.
Cahyono is a researcher at the National Commission on
Human Rights (Komnas HAM) and Meinhover is a student of
Journalism and Global Studies at the University of Minnesota,
Minneapolis, USA. They can be reached at
icahyo17@yahoo.com and tedericco@gmail.com.